Chicago Blocks Demolition of Historic Motor Row Building

A landmark building in Chicago’s Motor Row District will be safeguarded, despite the owner’s intentions to tear it down in favor of a 21-story affordable senior housing complex.

The Commission on Chicago Landmarks unanimously voted to prevent the demolition of a historic building at 2347 South Michigan Avenue, marking a significant preservation decision in the Motor Row District, the Chicago Sun Times reported.

The two-story structure, dating to 1910, was originally a Fiat showroom and is noted for its role in showcasing early automotive models. The building later became infamous as the site of the E2 nightclub, where 21 people tragically died in a stampede in 2003.

Property owner Randy Shifrin was angered by the commission’s decision. Shifrin, who said he was not informed of the meeting, criticized the move as a setback for his redevelopment plans, which also included a long-awaited memorial for the E2 victims. He argued that the city’s actions hinder efforts to provide housing and fulfill promises of a memorial.

The commission said its decision was based on the building’s historical and architectural significance rather than the nightclub’s history.

A mix-up involving a letter from the city’s Buildings Department, which Shifrin received in May and interpreted as authorization for demolition, added to the confusion. The Buildings Department later clarified that the letter was poorly worded and did not permit demolition.

The building was designed by the renowned architectural firm Holabird & Roche and features a well-preserved façade of brick and terra cotta, which the commission deemed crucial to maintaining the integrity of the Motor Row District.

Two other historic Chicago buildings were saved from demolition recently. The U.S. General Services Commission reversed its decision to tear down the 16-story Century building at 202 South State Street and the 22-story Consumers building at 220 South State Street.

— Andrew Terrell